The Green Tortoise sounds like the Hampton Jitney. We went to the Hamptons on Vaca in the off season a few years back. The LIRR has a limited schedule during winter, we took the LIRR out there butt the Jitney back to Manhattan. It was okay.
Jersey Mike's is not my fave, it just happens to be next door from getting my hair fixed.
Never tried Firehouse, maybe sum day. We've donated to tunnels to towers and to the Tennessee tornado, so I guess I will have to try a firehouse.