Replies to post #12112 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[Susie924]

I thought the same thing about the other contestants.

She beats to a different drummer, that's for sure. Even her father said as much.

I think her downfall was the same thing that people liked her for in the beginning. The scream became overdone.

[djr63]

I'm thinking maybe she was in shock? I wasn't expecting her to go this early.