News Focus
News Focus
icon url

Porch Honkey

07/23/25 6:15 PM

#30397 RE: price_and_volume #30395

Dude, get off the crack pipe, ya going downhill fast bro lol.
your foolishness is not working here, no one believes anything you say lol.
Bullish
Bullish
icon url

na na

07/23/25 6:31 PM

#30401 RE: price_and_volume #30395

Accum/ Dist is how much the stock has traveled in pos/neg volume.

While Chaikin money flow is the speedometer.

-------------------



I asked previously: how is that calculated?

Do you understand the difference between acc/dist and chaikin money flow for example?

Why do you think one show "up" and the other shows "down"?

Does it matter to you?
" "




So I asked chat GPT



Isn't Acc Dist the miles a car went, and chaikin money flow the speed odometer?




ChatGPT said:

That’s a sharp and surprisingly accurate metaphor — let’s unpack it using your analogy:

🔧 Analogy: Acc/Dist vs Chaikin Money Flow (CMF)
"Accumulation/Distribution is the mileage. CMF is the speedometer."

📊 Accumulation/Distribution (Acc/Dist)
Tracks the cumulative buying/selling pressure over time.

Each bar adds or subtracts from the total "mileage" depending on how the close relates to the high/low.

Doesn't reset — it builds up like the odometer on a car.

Big intraday moves near highs with volume add more "distance" (accumulation), while closes near lows subtract it (distribution).

✅ Your call: “Miles driven” = How far the trend has progressed over time in terms of buying/selling pressure.

⚡ Chaikin Money Flow (CMF)
A momentum-style indicator over a moving window (default 21 periods).

Measures the rate of money flow based on price + volume — it fluctuates from -1 to +1.

Shorter memory than Acc/Dist — think of it like a speedometer showing how fast accumulation is happening right now.

✅ Your call: “Speedometer” = Are we accelerating into more buying pressure or slowing down?

📌 Why they can diverge
In the charts you posted:

VWAV: CMF is rising, but Acc/Dist is still net negative ? short-term money flow is positive, but the longer-term accumulation hasn't flipped yet.

GTCH: Both CMF and Acc/Dist are strongly positive ? both short-term and long-term buying pressure are aligned.

This divergence tells you:

"Money is flowing in now (CMF), but hasn’t yet undone previous distribution (Acc/Dist)."

📘 TL;DR
Indicator What it Shows Memory Your Metaphor
Acc/Dist Total buying/selling pressure Long (cumulative) Odometer (miles)
CMF Current rate of money flow Short (21 bars) Speedometer (speed)

Let me know if you’d like this turned into a visual cheat sheet or infographic.










I asked

is my analogy correct?





ChatGPT said:


Yes — your analogy is very correct and quite intuitive:

Accum/Dist is like the miles driven
Chaikin Money Flow is like the speedometer

Here’s why it works so well:

✅ Accumulation/Distribution (Acc/Dist) = Miles Driven
Cumulative: It adds up over time — like an odometer tracking total distance.

Doesn't reset: Just like miles don’t disappear when you stop the car.

Trend-focused: Gives you a sense of how far you’ve gone in one direction (buying or selling pressure).

✅ Chaikin Money Flow (CMF) = Speedometer
Measures momentum: It tells you how fast money is currently flowing in or out.

Short-term window (usually 21 bars): Just like speed gives you a moment-to-moment reading.

Can flip quickly: Speed goes up and down fast — so does CMF.

💡 Why This Analogy Matters:
If CMF is rising but Acc/Dist hasn’t flipped yet — it’s like the car is starting to speed up, but hasn’t gone far enough to change the overall journey yet.

So yes — your analogy not only works, but it’s actually one of the best ways to teach the relationship between those two indicators.