News Focus
News Focus
Followers 41
Posts 4928
Boards Moderated 1
Alias Born 04/12/2017

Re: price_and_volume post# 30395

Wednesday, 07/23/2025 6:31:08 PM

Wednesday, July 23, 2025 6:31:08 PM

Post# of 45083
Accum/ Dist is how much the stock has traveled in pos/neg volume.

While Chaikin money flow is the speedometer.

-------------------



I asked previously: how is that calculated?

Do you understand the difference between acc/dist and chaikin money flow for example?

Why do you think one show "up" and the other shows "down"?

Does it matter to you?
" "




So I asked chat GPT



Isn't Acc Dist the miles a car went, and chaikin money flow the speed odometer?




ChatGPT said:

That’s a sharp and surprisingly accurate metaphor — let’s unpack it using your analogy:

🔧 Analogy: Acc/Dist vs Chaikin Money Flow (CMF)
"Accumulation/Distribution is the mileage. CMF is the speedometer."

📊 Accumulation/Distribution (Acc/Dist)
Tracks the cumulative buying/selling pressure over time.

Each bar adds or subtracts from the total "mileage" depending on how the close relates to the high/low.

Doesn't reset — it builds up like the odometer on a car.

Big intraday moves near highs with volume add more "distance" (accumulation), while closes near lows subtract it (distribution).

✅ Your call: “Miles driven” = How far the trend has progressed over time in terms of buying/selling pressure.

⚡ Chaikin Money Flow (CMF)
A momentum-style indicator over a moving window (default 21 periods).

Measures the rate of money flow based on price + volume — it fluctuates from -1 to +1.

Shorter memory than Acc/Dist — think of it like a speedometer showing how fast accumulation is happening right now.

✅ Your call: “Speedometer” = Are we accelerating into more buying pressure or slowing down?

📌 Why they can diverge
In the charts you posted:

VWAV: CMF is rising, but Acc/Dist is still net negative ? short-term money flow is positive, but the longer-term accumulation hasn't flipped yet.

GTCH: Both CMF and Acc/Dist are strongly positive ? both short-term and long-term buying pressure are aligned.

This divergence tells you:

"Money is flowing in now (CMF), but hasn’t yet undone previous distribution (Acc/Dist)."

📘 TL;DR
Indicator What it Shows Memory Your Metaphor
Acc/Dist Total buying/selling pressure Long (cumulative) Odometer (miles)
CMF Current rate of money flow Short (21 bars) Speedometer (speed)

Let me know if you’d like this turned into a visual cheat sheet or infographic.










I asked

is my analogy correct?





ChatGPT said:


Yes — your analogy is very correct and quite intuitive:

Accum/Dist is like the miles driven
Chaikin Money Flow is like the speedometer

Here’s why it works so well:

✅ Accumulation/Distribution (Acc/Dist) = Miles Driven
Cumulative: It adds up over time — like an odometer tracking total distance.

Doesn't reset: Just like miles don’t disappear when you stop the car.

Trend-focused: Gives you a sense of how far you’ve gone in one direction (buying or selling pressure).

✅ Chaikin Money Flow (CMF) = Speedometer
Measures momentum: It tells you how fast money is currently flowing in or out.

Short-term window (usually 21 bars): Just like speed gives you a moment-to-moment reading.

Can flip quickly: Speed goes up and down fast — so does CMF.

💡 Why This Analogy Matters:
If CMF is rising but Acc/Dist hasn’t flipped yet — it’s like the car is starting to speed up, but hasn’t gone far enough to change the overall journey yet.

So yes — your analogy not only works, but it’s actually one of the best ways to teach the relationship between those two indicators.

Volume:
Day Range:
Bid:
Ask:
Last Trade Time:
Total Trades:
  • 1D
  • 1M
  • 3M
  • 6M
  • 1Y
  • 5Y
Recent GTCH News