Replies to post #15569 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

wow, i cant wait to……..

…

watch it tonight and comment but yes, i never understood confetti any time on this show.. poor abi, lol.

and wow, im thrilled to hear whiny crybaby emmy is gone. super sweet girl but she is NOT her grandmother and thats all that carried her along so far. sweet girl but thats all and she needs mental help. she is very depressed.

i think jack will when, but im happy with all 3 for now.

i dont think the finale is next week, dont they kick off one and then the 2 compete last?

[gail]

my take……..

….

round 1-

- abi- i see what you are saying about confetti in the mouth but she handled it well, but i didnt care for the song.

- triston- it was ok but just “meh” and he was so much better earlier in the show

- emmy- horrible as usual

- jack- it was good but boring. have you noticed no more dried spit in his lips lately? sorry, but someone has to say it to him and i think someone did so they either have him drinking more water or something.. i think he will win this. he has more talent over all, than the others, with moving around, engaging the audience, etc.

- will- odd song and not a good job on this one.

round 2-

- emmy- horrible again.

- triston- his poem to his mom got me sappy… he sang a hard song to do and it was NOT good.

- abi- rough start and just meh later on.

- jack- kids wont understand this old song but it was really good.

- will- he told his mom “you ain’t losing me, just sharing me” wow, what a great line! this was his type of song but it was just “meh” for me.

- you said emmy and triston go, so i cut the show off before that part.