News Focus
News Focus
Replies to #212303 on Just Politics
icon url

blackhawks

07/16/23 11:33 AM

#212304 RE: BullNBear52 #212303

A shorter read:

https://www.amherst.edu/media/view/22912/original/Descartes%2B-%2BOntological%2BArgument.pdf

The Ontological Argument
Simple Version


In Meditation 5, Descartes’ argument for the existence of God looks something like this:

1. My idea of God is the idea of a supremely perfect being.
2. Existence is a perfection.
3. Therefore, God exists.

It seems at the outset that there is something strange about this argument. The is suspicion is confirmed
when we realize that a similar argument can prove the existence of a supremely perfect island:

1. I have an idea of a supremely perfect island.
2. Existence is a perfection.
3. Therefore, a supremely perfect island exists.

Of course we can run a similar argument for a supremely perfect raisin, a supremely perfect
cheeseburger, and so forth. Something must be wrong with Descartes’ argument.
icon url

janice shell

07/16/23 5:21 PM

#212306 RE: BullNBear52 #212303

The new "guidelines" are only for stock boards. Moderators of premium boards like this one can continue to show trolls the door.