Replies to post #77991 on Tesla Inc (TSLA)

[boston745]

If EMC not maintained properly these systems may malfunction or even may fail to operate.

If we see the electric vehicle architecture large amount of electrical and electronic systems placed into a confined space. This causes electromagnetic interference or cross talk between these systems. If EMC not maintained properly these systems may malfunction or even may fail to operate.

Below is the image showing all the internal sources of EMI in most modern vehicles. While there are sources within ICE vehicles they are far fewer in number and more importantly far smaller EMFs as the voltage and amperage does not come close to that which EVs require.



One of the problems with established guidelines for proper EMC maybe because of the following:

Outside tests are done in a real-world on road driving conditions. In these tests the vehicle under test need to drive with maximum acceleration and deceleration to ensure maximum current during traction and regenerative braking. These tests will be performed on straight road where the magnetic fields due to earth is constant and in some cases on steep slope roads. 

Automotive companies test their cars during calm geomagnetic activity. They have no way of being able to factor in potential magnetic variance from earths geomagnetic activity. As you can see from my last post, the 4 EVs that all went out of control did so all over the US. Maine, Michigan, Florida, & California. You never know where surface magnetic activity will interfere with a passing EV.



https://circuitdigest.com/article/electromagnetic-compatibility-in-electric-vehicles

[Entlarvt]

The tales of geomagnetic unrest and its alleged impact on electric vehicles continues !

"Several electric vehicle incidents during geomagnetic unrest."

Oh, the magnetism in the air! While it's true that there are occasional fluctuations in the Earth's magnetic field, linking them directly to sudden and unexplained car accidents requires more substantial evidence. Correlation does not imply causation.

"Four electric vehicles crashed suddenly during a 24-hour period."

A coincidence, or something more? It's worth considering the vast number of electric vehicles on the road today. With such a large fleet, statistically, there will be incidents occurring within a 24-hour period, regardless of geomagnetic activity.

"Electromagnetic Interference causing sudden unintended acceleration."

While electromagnetic interference is a legitimate concern, modern electric vehicles, including Teslas, are designed with robust shielding and safety measures to minimize such issues. Unintended acceleration is typically attributed to driver error or faults in specific vehicle systems, not the mystical forces of geomagnetic unrest.

"The mysterious Hutchison Effect and the Whompy Wheel."

Ah, the allure of classified national security secrets! While the Hutchison Effect might sound intriguing, its connection to Tesla's suspension or the phenomenon of "Whompy Wheels" remains purely speculative without scientific evidence. Let's not let imagination overshadow facts.

Regarding your questions with a sprinkle of humor:

Is there a strategy to distract people from looking at the basic data, like using humor? Well, humor can be an excellent tool to lighten the mood and encourage critical thinking. It's all about using it in the right context and not as a means to divert attention from evidence-based data.

Is the data being reduced to the absurd? Oh, no, quite the opposite! It's important to scrutinize the data, analyze it carefully, and separate valid information from baseless claims that may border on the absurd.
Is there an exercise to create more forum verbiage to drown out evidence?

Ah, the art of overwhelming forums with endless debates and verbose discussions. While forum chatter can be entertaining, it's essential to focus on credible sources, scientific research, and rigorous analysis to separate noise from valid evidence.

Remember, it's crucial to approach claims with a healthy dose of skepticism, rely on scientific research, and avoid attributing incidents to mysterious forces without robust evidence. Let's embrace rationality and critical thinking in our quest for understanding.