I think Fisher is right.
While the Jan poll showed the vast majority to be waaaaay off on this thread,(it would have to be almost impoossible to gather togather a group of folks whose average prediction for the market was 1000 on the comp and then have it be at almost 2000 9 months later. Could any group of investors, ANY be off nearly 100% on their prediction for a one year time frame???You have to admit, it doesn't get any worse than that.This is not the smart money here. Clearly.)
As this bull wears on, the folks on this thread are becoming more bullish. In another two years, they may be wildly bullish. If they get wildly bullish, that will probably be the top. So, the thread is a contrary indicator at extremes only, and to use that info, you have to broaden your time frame to a year, instead of using hourly charts, like those here and elsewhere.In between extremes, the thread will be trend following and will be quite accurate. It is up to us who want to WIN, and not just play, to figure out when trend following works.
This is what Fisher is saying and we see it here.