You sure that's a good idea with your dental issues? LOL. Cookies and Dreams for TJ's Cookies and Cream. Nightfood doesn't have a peanut butter flavored ice cream so it would be difficult to compare. Why don't you just give your opinion on any other flavor of your choice? You could test the sleep factor and eat some prior to going to bed. I think on average most people eat about 1/2 the container at at time .