"(PPHM proved in the past that they NEVER EVER abused the ATM for anything else then contengency (dose switching) or funding (Sunrise, Avid, etc)."
That is an opinion. It's hard to prove an opinion. In my opinion paying themselves millions in salaries over the years for nothing but failure and a 95% drop in pps is abusing the ATM.
You left out the $60m+ that they spent to get Cotara to where it now sits in the shelf. Maybe not abuse but certainly not money well spent. Unless you still think that this too is not a failure.