Replies to post #32806 on S&P 500 & Nasdaq Analysis and Trends

[Stock]

There are THREE problems with the Hirsch Organization MACD timing NASDAQ page:

1. It says "NASDAQ 500 BEST SIX MONTHS STRATEGY + TIMING" - there is no NASDAQ 500 that I am aware of.

2. It shows an exit date of "8-Jun-06 2060.18" which was actually the closing price on 8-Jun-2005



3. There is NO posted exit date for the NASDAQ for 2006. I ASSUME they meant April 10, 2006, which would have been the close I posted: 10-Apr-06 2333.27 OR 2310.35 on 11-Apr-06??

[Stock]

Interesting: I tried to line up the DAILY MACD signal with the WEEKLY Williams %R signal I have been following, and this was what I found -- it wasn't easy to line up the chart dates but this is close.



Search terms: MACD Williams %R Hirsch Hirschorg.com

[quiet]

Thanks for sharing. A lot of good things to consider.

[3xBuBu]

worm, what is the criteria for entry and exit?
NASDAQ COMPOSITE MACD Signal Date (Entry) 2005 - 19-Oct-05 2091.76
NASDAQ COMPOSITE MACD Signal Date (Exit) 2006 - 10-Apr-06 2333.27

[Stock]

$COMPQ, however, is anything but negative

[Stock]

Nasdaq Composite daily and weekly

[Stock]

Best Six Months Strategy - NASDAQ COMPOSITE (3,000)

Gerald Appel recommends an 8-17-9 MACD to generate buy signals and a 12-25-9 MACD to confirm a sell signal for a stock, which has had a strong bullish move.