matt, all very good points by you, however, here is where it might not work
same thing was done at raging bull, a clubboard was formed for idcc, what happened was, everybody stopped using the main board, so that the main board became irrelevant, and nobody could challenge anyone on the clubboard or ask tough questions, because they would be banned, i understand everybody hates once at the idcc board, but to me it makes it more interesting to have all different points of view, as long as it does not get personal
believe me, if there was an idcc clubboard again, i doubt i would be able to post, and as u have seen i rarely get personal, i just am a skeptic to some of these posts
anyway i understand your frustration at all the time wasted, however like you said a lot of time could be saved by people just ignoring the posters they don't like
if u decide on what you are doing, could you send me a message explaining the new rules, if not i am sure i will hear about on the grapevine, thanks