That's the problem with analogies. Personally, I like to use them, but it's considered a really poor way to try to apply logic.
What you're doing is taking the analogy and saying that because certain aspects are similar, all aspects are the same. The kind of logic that has blades of grass becoming sequioa if you don't mow them.
But I don't recall offering opinions about any stock here. Please point out to me where I have.