Jonnytrade: if you take assumptions A, B, and C, and deduce from them winning trades, or at least positions other traders consider shrewd, then am I supposed to have you give me the conclusion without the reasoning?? The reason for the existence of this board is for the education and betterment of traders and their skills. If a good trader explains why he is trading, and you dont listen, it is your loss. If he is restricted from presenting his argument, many people potentially lose. If you feel strongly, put him on ignore.
This is a topic with strong emotions, which I understand. But there is no other action that serves the purpose of the board.
Oddlot