I will have to check the NEW 5 Gal Bucket, but I think this is exactly what I got today. Home Depot did take back my 5 gal bucket from last fall. They tried to make me feel like it was my fault for buying the wrong type of base. I was not falling for it. I said in almost every case I have gone to get a paint of any kind, the sales assnt. usually will ask what I am planning to do with it, and they should have pointed out that what I bought last year was NOT translucent, and would not show the natural wood grain. They started to throw all kinds of Deck painting/staining terms at me about degrees of base tones etc. I just said, hold it, perfect example right now, because your are speaking a Foreign language to me. Now if we were talking about indoor house paints, now that's a language that I understand.....