Replies to post #58037 on The Question and Answer Board (IHUB)

[gotmilk]

re: "[IH t-shirt] contest with a three-judge panel"

Yes we need better control this time, and since grub(Dave)bladder
was not associated with the prior contest, he should guarantee that those
most responsible to the last "successfull" tag lines will not exercise
the same "control" over what is resulted.

For example Dave can list those IH members that "won" via their suggestion
of a tag line that ended up on the t-shirt.

Not sure but I think a member actually had 3 of their suggestions
placed onto the t-shirt, and look what the awful outcome was.

Investors Hub Online Store Item Detail: Tagline T-Shirt

... and the winning Tagline entries on the back

THE "winning" .... ya, like... :o)

[Capt_Nemo]

2- Bob, Grubmaster and Matt work with three main judges on rules and all agree to stick to the rules no matter what!




HERE HERE haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[Bob Zumbrunnen]

If we go the route of having a 3-judge panel, or simply using the Survey system to gather community votes, the bottom line is whatever route we take has to have as little of my involvement as possible. I just want to eventually end up with a list of what I'm buying.

But there won't be any rules-changing or anything like that. If we set out to do it as a Survey-based community vote thing, that's what we'll stick with. Same if we select 3 judges from the community.

And by "we", I really mean Dave and Matt. <g>