If you had started with this: "Mr Carraway lost a sh-t load of the investors money on a losing business. In order to claim these losses against future earnings someone would have to know where the old checkstubs are."
instead of these: "The accumulated NOL should be over $10M." "Certifying the financials would be well worth the effort in my opinion."
.......you wouldn't have heard a peep out of me. But you didn't. And the NOL wasn't and isn't over $10M and finding the old checkstubs doesn't require certifying the financials. Those points needed correcting.