>>Then we would be giving monk's class away for free<<
No it's not. Signing up at profit.ly (or any other verified trader resource) and showing your trades is just that showing your entries and exits.
No one would know your technique. There's no rhyme or reason and most have various techniques. Some follow TA, some follow FA, some combine, some just look for movers and could care less about the company.
If everyone is using the same technique then why are some of the den members claiming to not being successful and not having anymore funds to trade with?
To say being transparent with your trades would be giving monk's class away free is ridiculous IMO