I am not sure how one "grades" calls so I did not take that "worst" adjective too seriously myself. It surely was not the worst, since the market did not open with a bang but gave us a 20 points retrenchment on the Naz. I have been caught with my pants down more than once thinking the market will "zag and it zigged", particularly on very short term calls. The way to handle such posts is simply to assume that the person in the excitement of the minute exaggerated a little. (g). Ganging on him is not "fruitful" and that is what I meant (also in the heat of the moment) by "getting at each other's throat".