Okay so I'm seeing what is going on here. I needed more volatility or when the put rallied to $2.50 I should have sold it for the profit and held the call and run the risk of it going worthless or bouncing back and recovering some of the capital. Still at $2.50 I would have had around a $1600 profit so a worthless call would have put me at -$700 on the trade. Elevated risk and speculation doing that.
I guess I could have sold the put and taken the profits and rolled into a higher out of the money put at 21.00 but now I'm spread wider. That is not good. Thinking out loud.
current position ---------------- 10Oct20c @1.36 XLFJT $1360 10Oct20p @1.70 XLFVT $1700 total value $3060
original position ---------------- buy 10Oct20c @2.30 XLFJT $2300 + 17.49com buy 10Oct20p @ .90 XLFVT $ 900 + 17.49com total cost $3234.98