News Focus
News Focus
icon url

Zeev Hed

04/17/04 3:11 PM

#41085 RE: UBGreen #41081

Bernie, "balls" are not enough, such a President must leave in his wake a scene that leaves us and the world safer than the scene he inherited. By lowering the threshold for defensive preemptive strike, the world is made less safe in the future when small regional conflicts are initiated based on similar standards of "clear and present danger".

By choosing to remove Saddam by force rather than by stealth, or even bribe (I am sure that with 10% of the Iraq cost of now $200 B, Saddam toppling could have been achieved peacefully), we incur major financial problems, when we can least afford it (butter and gun policy is what led to the 70' economic malaise...).

Shifting the tax burden from corporations and top earners to retired people, does not put money in consumer pockets endangering the sustainability of the current recovery. (in the 50/60, during Republican rule and up to about 63, corporations paid 21% plus of the tax burden, today, less than 8%, is that what Modern Republicans believe should be the fair tax burden sharing?)

It is not a question of liking Bush or not, I am a Republican fiscal conservative, on the verge of being an isolationist, and as such the current fiscal profligacy is, IMHO, an error. It is the policies that I abhor, not the person. I don't know Bush well enough to like or dislike him.

As for foreign policy, creating an artificial break with Germany and France, as not unavoidable, and an error. Furthermore, as an other instance, what would have been lost if in his common statement with Sharon, he would have accepted only "minor realignment" to the 67 lines, rather than going gang ho one sidedly and essentially taking the larger settlements off the negotiation table? What would have hurt our international policy if he would have emphasized that it is up to the Palestinians to accelerate the peace process rather than slow it down, since the longer they wait, the less "practical" it would be to dismantle major settlements in the west bank.

For that matter, how about some original thinking on the west bank, what if the settlement issues was dealt separately of a peace agreement and borders agreement, and the settlers would either chose to leave, if they are deep within the future "Palestinian State", or stay and accept Palestinian citizenship, just as Arabs in Israel have Israeli citizenship? Why is it necessary to uproot these settlements if there is peace between the two countries? Are they suggesting that a peace agreement will involve resettling Arabs from Um el Pahem to Jericho, or Abu Gosh to Hebron? Do we really need another Punjab?
icon url

Rick Louden

04/17/04 6:44 PM

#41112 RE: UBGreen #41081

Bernie, you bring up an interesting point that I've thought about as a Republican and as someone who believes that one year ago the Administration truly believed SH was dangerous to the United States and had WMD.

I agree with you that George Bush does "have the balls" to stand up for what he believes is right and at the time, the decision to attack Iraq may have been the right one given the information Bush had. It is that same quality of making firm decisions and standing tall that I admired about Ronald Reagan. However, Reagan was able to do it without turning the world against us. Even those who disagreed tended to respect him (at his prime). And anyone who met him in person, went away liking him. We can't say that about Bush and for that reason it is unlikely that Bush will go down as a great President. Bush may stand up for what he believes, and perhaps his decisions are good....only a greater power knows for sure. But one thing is sure. He is a lousy politician. And like it or not, his effectiveness as President will involve more than making firm decisions. He needs the rest of the world to see those decisions as logical, reasonable, and humane. And that is not happening.

So unfortunately, he hasn't turned out to be the President this Republican thought he would be. And personally I doubt he will go down as great or even mediocre unless something changes soon.........

Rick
icon url

webster groves

04/17/04 11:23 PM

#41150 RE: UBGreen #41081

I'm sure all Israelis are equally proud of Bush. But do you think that would translate into votes ? What do you think Bush's chances would be getting elected to the Knesset ?

wg