What I would like have happen to me is not a point of discussion, so there is no debate in that regard.
"dont think there is any debate as to what you would like to have happen to you."
The example I provided is an example of a strategy that apllies to all past, present and future market "situations".
"but your example is looking at a situation that has passed"
True, but one system is overwhelmingly more reliable than the other.
"You both are right, but your systems are completely different."