usta: You have no idea of exactly how correct your first line paragraph was. But it is a two way street though. I think you can enjoy the view...but if it isn't the best picture then you just need to chalk it up to live.
I think that the 'good cheer' can get lost on these places. Everyone knows that, as an employee of the company, you can't be popping into these places and yakking it up about what may be coming down the line. On the other hand, operating under the premise that we're here because we actually own the stock ( something that the RB board mentality has gotten away from in my opinion ) we can mention thing's that just come across our plate every once in a while. I think it serves to steady the nerves, especially since you probably own the stock. However, what I view as x, another may view as y or z.
I guess, in the end, it comes down to how hard someone is willing to extend themselves. I just believe that if the source isn't connected to the company, and you can confirm it by way of another source ( ala the N.Y. Times back in May/June ) then press on and do it.
I've found this: When you have "guessed" right, a heck of a lot of people will sleep a lot better knowing that they're not getting fed a line. I think the owners of the shares feel this way. On the other hand, if someone is not an owner of the shares...then they can just sit back and have it both ways. It's easier to tear something apart than it is to build it.
Ahhhh...philosophy. usta...Have a great day!
Cal