News Focus
News Focus
icon url

fuagf

02/06/24 9:26 PM

#460844 RE: arizona1 #460842

Agree from the evidence i've read so far that of hers has little real scientific basis. I posted it just to give it an airing. That said if good evidence arises supporting Navratilova's position then i'd agree with her that it is one area which should be farther looked at. Just grabbed this one

Listen To The Voices Of Female Athletes

Donna Lopiano
Contributor
I’m an organizational policy wonk with a focus on current sport issues

Jan 17, 2024,12:14am EST

A just released January 2024 UK report on the transgender athlete in women's sport issue .. https://fairplayforwomen.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/How-inclusion-in-sport-is-harming-women-and-girls-by-Fair-Play-For-Women-14-Jan-2024.pdf .. features the voices of females (biological girls and women) who have experienced sports competing against transgender athletes. From grassroots recreational sport to national and international levels of competitive sport, as well as from the insides of changing rooms and rest rooms, girls and women from 35 sports are speaking out. Their voices are speaking clearly about how they are being adversely affected by policies which allow males who identify as women to compete in women’s sport.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/donnalopiano/2024/01/17/listen-to-the-voices-of-female-athletes/?sh=6691a7171d6e

Haven't read it yet. And i don't know yet, but it wouldn't surprise me if that 'fairplayforwomen' at least leaned toward anti-trans women ..
https://www.facebook.com/fairplayforwomen/posts/we-need-your-help-please-complain-to-the-bbc-about-this-shoddy-and-biased-articl/460649344345214/ .

Only that one for now.
icon url

B402

02/06/24 11:33 PM

#460849 RE: arizona1 #460842

6-0 in five minutes,,,you progressives just befuddle people....



simple data, if your common sense fails...

Women's world record 100m dash 10.49
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women%27s_100_metres_world_record_progression

10.49 ranks 1138th among men........The top 1100 men could set the women's 'world record'..
https://worldathletics.org/records/toplists/sprints/100-metres/outdoor/men/senior/2022?page=12

Lia Thomas was ranked 462 as a man and set NCAA records as a woman...

Yet progressives continue to double down on stupid chit and drag the democratic party down with you.....
icon url

sortagreen

02/07/24 6:47 AM

#460857 RE: arizona1 #460842

I usually try to stay out of this one. I'm not an expert, but I can say this... On the subject of the human sexual experience (if that's the word I'm looking for), I don't have a problem with people wanting to be what they are; I posted last week that the Talmud recognizes 6 or possibly 8 genders along a spectrum of human sexuality, so this is not a modern invention. The number's debatable. (They count eunuchs which is clearly man-made thing) But this shouldn't be an argument. Lia Thomas should be ashamed of itself. Period. Full stop. So should the morons who thought that allowing (him/her) to compete. I'd leave it to an actual sports doctor to say whether prepubescent boys can compete fairly with girls, but Lia Thomas has a fully developed adult male body. You may as well allow competitors to take steroids and male hormone shots. There would be no difference.

*****************************
Some points.

Caitlyn Jenner (as an Olympic gold medalist) couldn't win in a woman's golf tournament.

Bruce Jenner was not a golfer. Have any of his competitive records been bested by women athletes?


Has she seen some of the heterosexual women's softball players?

Well, hetero may be case by case there. But that doesn't really hold up. Have you seen the men? I mean, I couldn't compete in the women's hammer throw or shot put, but there's a reason that men and women don't compete against each other in those events.

*****************************

As far as girls holding the edge in the spelling bee? I know you're joking.

* 97 isn't a large enough sample to draw any conclusions and even then, it's close.
* The contestants are drawn from a niche pool. How many, much smarter kids never compete in that arena? And are they male, or female, or somewhere in between? Sports is far more universal and the sample sizes are enormous
* And lastly, rote learning shows us only one facet of human intelligence.