Joe, there is an old saying: Never wrestle with a pig -- you both get dirty, and the pig likes it.
toogoodfella is not a native speaker of English, and he's not fluent. Years ago when I drilled down into his arguments about COD income and the specific rules governing who receives form 1099-C, he had some rather unique ways of parsing sentences and defining words that were at odds with standard usage.
There's no point in arguing with toogood. To paraphrase the physicist Wolfgang Pauli on the subject of a hopelessly misguided theory, he is not even wrong. But he likes getting dirty.