...(prior to January 1, 2013), the skeptical posters have been more right than wrong.
Shorter term (since January 1, 2013), I think the optimistic and pessimistic crowd are a draw. The high post guys can talk of 3- and 4-year low but over the last year, the share price is basically at a stand still. I know the S&P is up 25% in that time period but one doesn't usually invest in a high risk equity without looking for huge returns. If SIAF's day does come, the returns will be a helluva lot bigger than 25%.
Kind of illustrates how cheap posting on the daily price action is IMO. The share price is a roller coaster. One day the positive posts will be correct and twenty minutes later, the negative posts will be correct.
Probably best to avoid all posts on daily price action.