>>I have seen him called far worse on the Rants board and have seen no corrective action taken!
That's a "club"/group board, that's run solely by the Moderator, unless something major happens.
>>The problem is you are running a business and acting as judge and jury.
While true to an extent, they work well together, for the most part. If someone needs to be booted off for being a troublemarker, it probably benefits the business.