Matt, if you see this:
The 209.* routes died, apparently. Don't know if that was intentional or not. Both sites were inaccessible via http.
I switched the Internet NICs to 207.* as metric 1, 209.* as metric 2, and 216.* as metric 3. Amazingly, the 216.* addresses still work. Name resolution is still screwed up, but that's cosmetic. (Guess the servers are still in Texas. <g>)
In DNS, everything now points to the 207.* addresses except for a couple that still point to 216.* IPs. You can sort that out.
iHub's IIS was bitching about unique binding, but I got it working by deleting all of the 207.* entries and reentering them. I still don't think it is configured right, but I bitched to you about that previously.
Lastly, we need to confirm that we are pointing to a legitimate DNS server. I suppose that can wait.