I've posted the Nature piece because it is more balanced than Derek's, whose piece was referred to as provocative.
LOL—my characterization of Derek Lowe’s Sirtris piece as provocative was a tactful way of saying that I thought he was out to lunch. Lowe is vastly overrated as a blogger, IMO.
Thanks for restoring some balance to the discussion.
“The efficient-market hypothesis may be the foremost piece of B.S. ever promulgated in any area of human knowledge!”