Home > Boards > The Lounge > Politics > Simply Politics (GOV)


Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgReplies (1) | Next 10 | Previous | Next
wstera2 Member Profile
Member Level 
Followed By 4
Posts 820
Boards Moderated 0
Alias Born 02/06/01
160x600 placeholder
Kansas City Fed Services Activity Index Rises in January
By Colin Kellaher
Apple Up Over 5%, on Track for Largest Percent Increase Since October 2020 -- Data Talk
Intel on Track for Lowest Close Since December 2020 -- Data Talk
Visa Up Over 5%, on Pace for Largest Percent Increase Since November 2020 -- Data Talk
Oil Prices Seen at $78 This Year as Supply Hikes Lag Demand
US Consumer Sentiment Wanes in Late January to Decade-Low on Inflation Concerns
Insulet Shares Rally on FDA Approval of Omnipod 5
Provention Bio Shares Rise 13% After Plan to Resubmit BLA
Pfizer Gets EC OK for Lorviqua as First-Line Treatment for ALK-Positive Advanced Lung Cancer
Citi Works With Five Black-Owned Firms on Bond Issuance
Top Company News of the Day
U.S. Consumer Spending Fell 0.6% in December
Eli Lilly Reports Olumiant Setbacks in Lupus, Atopic Dermatitis
FTSE Down, Long Gilts Could Remain in Sweet Spot
Colgate-Palmolive Expects Earnings Growth This Year
Chevron Hits Production High in 2021, Net Output Down 5% in 4Q -- Energy Comment
Regeneron, Sanofi Pull FDA Application for Libtayo in Advanced Cervical Cancer
Bristol Myers Gets Positive CHMP Opinion For Breyanzi in Lymphoma
Colgate-Palmolive 4Q Profit Falls, Hit by Higher Costs
Merck: Molnupiravir Covid-19 Pill Effective Against Omicron in Lab Tests
EUROPEAN MIDDAY BRIEFING - Stocks Fall Ahead of Expected Mixed US Open
Insulet Gets FDA OK for Omnipod 5 Automated Insulin-Delivery System
North American Morning Briefing: S&P 500, Dow on Track for Fourth Weekly Loss
BOE Seen Trying to Encourage Stronger Pound, Says ING
Givaudan Shares Slide on Weak Profitability, Costs Impact
Belgian Economy Grew in 4Q at a Slower Pace
FTSE 100 Drops as Oil, Mining, Financial Stocks Fall
Henkel Shares Slide as 2022 Targets Fall Short of Consensus
wstera2 Member Level  Tuesday, 11/02/04 01:39:38 PM
Re: PegnVA post# 11319
Post # of 436354 

Kerry's Pollster: We're Going To Lose

This has got to be disheartening for Democrats. John Kerry's pollster is apparently predicting defeat...

“We simply do not defeat an incumbent president in wartime.”

The quote above is from Mark Mellman. Mark is a Democratic pollster. And he’s very partisan. And he’s been working for Kerry this year.

But Mark is no fool and he has a reputation to maintain.

He explains his reasoning at some length in a column in The Hill this morning. He predicts that Bush will get 51.6% of the two-party vote."

If Matthew Dowd were saying it was over for Bush before it started that would be pretty depressing.


Mark Mellman

The uphill fight is impossible to predict now

You, dear reader, have the advantage over me. I am writing this Sunday, before the election takes place. The opportunities for me to look foolish are legion. So I will resist both predictions and triumphalism.

For months, though, I’ve been assessing President Bush’s vulnerability, but win or lose, it is important to acknowledge the daunting challenge Sen. John Kerry faces.
Republicans have been spinning this fact for months and they are right.

First, we simply do not defeat an incumbent president in wartime. After wars surely, but never in their midst. Republicans have been spinning this fact for months, and they are correct.

Democrats have spoken often and powerfully about the nation’s economic problems. But by historical standards, they are not that bad. The “misery index” is 7.8 today but was 20.5 when Jimmy Carter was defeated. Economic models of elections show Bush winning 52-58 percent of the vote.

One could simply suggest that the models are off, but there is more to it than that.

These models essentially confirm that the level of economic pain we are now feeling is not commensurate with voting an incumbent president out of office.

Unemployment and inflation are lower than they have been when incumbents have been defeated. Growth is higher than it has been when presidents have been tossed out of office.

The war in Iraq is obviously hurting Bush, but some of these models also incorporate casualty figures as a proxy for war. These models tend to suggest that Bush should win by a large margin. Nearly 50,000 killed in Vietnam did not prevent Nixon’s reelection.

Bush’s approval ratings are also indicative of the difficulties Kerry faces. It is certainly true that the average incumbent who has been reelected has had a much higher job approval rating — 62 percent. Bush’s approval rating is now about 49 percent. Yet the last time an incumbent was beaten — Bush’s father — just 33 percent approved of his performance. When Carter was defeated, he had an approval rating of only 37 percent. On average, incumbents who have been defeated have only had a 38 percent job rating. Bush is 10 points higher than that.

We often point to the fact that a majority of Americans say the country is seriously off on the wrong track. Fifty-two percent hold that view. But when Bush Sr. was defeated, 72 percent thought the country was seriously off on the wrong track.

Only 39 percent give the economy a positive rating, a problem for the incumbent.

Yet in 1992, only about 10 percent were positive about the economy.

Taking all that and more into account, an expert forecasting model suggests that Bush will get 51.6 percent of the two-party vote.

So while Bush faces formidable obstacles, not the least of which is Kerry himself, the senator also faces a strong candidate. Bush is weaker than some other incumbents but much stronger than those who have been defeated.

You soon will know whether Kerry’s appeal was strong enough to overcome the incumbent’s strength. I think I will be smiling broadly. But it has been an uphill fight.

Mellman is president of The Mellman Group and has worked for Democratic candidates and causes since 1982, including Sen. John Kerry this year.


Public Reply | Private Reply | Keep | Last ReadPost New MsgReplies (1) | Next 10 | Previous | Next
Follow Board Follow Board Keyboard Shortcuts Report TOS Violation
Current Price
Detailed Quote - Discussion Board
Intraday Chart
+/- to Watchlist
Consent Preferences