Did you check out Progressive for auto? We found one company recently that beat their rates but not by that much so didn't go to the trouble of changing...yet.
Why'd you dump AARP and AAA? Who did you get?
Got mine through Hubby's bizness, so far am happy with them. But one Sis went through a lot of med probs this past year and her ins was NOT adequate. They went into the proverbial financial hole with their 80/20 plan and high deductible - feel very sorry for them.