Chico-You are right, I have been watching the action on the 5" swing chart all day long and it very good and looks very tradeable. I closed out my long about noon for 40 ticks, 1.45% then DID NOT EXECUTE a short signal at 2:00 because of the 5 minute chart. I then got a long signal at 3:00 and switched to the 5" swing chart. It had a text book entry. First Stoc xing was with 1:35 bar. MACD xing was with 2:20 bar, and then second Stoc xing with 3:10 bar somewhere around 28.30. Jon