JP 3E Holdings Inc (JPTE)

[keegers]

I know that your strategy applies to all markets, what I am saying is that it is tough for many to execute properly in real time. Hence the fact that the system looks nice and rosey when looking at past situations where it would work.

I do agree, the system you describe is more reliable in the sense that you have a chance to come out positive. But on the flip side one could attempt to implement the strategy you describe and the stock could drop out on them, causing them to lose even more than the guy who just sold and never re-bought.

So, this argument should be over for everyone involved. Buying high and selling low will lose you money. Buying high, selling low, buying lower AND having the price appreciate above the selling price will make you money. You need that key AND condition in there.