Tornado Alley (PROG)

[blackhawks]

More Futurism hyperbole and hysterics?

Amazon’s AWS Goes Down, Takes Out “Half of the Internet” "Really shows how easy it would be for Bezos and Ellison to just turn off the internet if they wanted to, for any reason." Fair?

The idea that Jeff Bezos and Larry Ellison could "just turn off the internet" is not fair and vastly overstates the power of any single individual or company, even one as large as Amazon Web Services (AWS).

The internet is a decentralized network of networks, meaning no one person, company, or government has the power to shut it all down.

Here is a breakdown of why this statement is inaccurate.

1. AWS is not the entire internet
While a single-region AWS outage, like the recent one in the US-EAST-1 data center, can cause significant disruption, it does not affect the whole internet.

Geographic distribution: AWS has dozens of data centers worldwide across multiple geographical regions. A problem in one region primarily impacts services hosted there, not all services globally.

Competing providers: While AWS is the largest cloud provider, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud are also major players. Many companies use multiple providers to improve resilience.

Local infrastructure: The internet also relies on millions of miles of undersea fiber optic cables, local internet service providers (ISPs), and in-home equipment to function. A cloud outage does not impact this foundational infrastructure.

2. Larry Ellison has limited influence on AWS
Larry Ellison, the founder of Oracle, has no control over Amazon's AWS. While Oracle is a competitor in the cloud space, any suggestion that Ellison and Bezos could conspire to turn off the internet is unfounded.

3. An outage is not a controlled shutdown
An outage is an unplanned system failure, not a deliberate act of sabotage. The recent AWS outage was attributed to an internal technical issue, such as a DNS error, not a malicious attack. In fact, engineers worked quickly to resolve the problem.

4. Decentralization is key to the internet's resilience
The internet's distributed architecture is its greatest strength.

Redundancy and rerouting: If one pathway or server goes down, data is automatically rerouted through an alternative path.

Server/Client model: The internet operates on a client-server model. If one server goes down, other servers and clients remain functional.

The real issue: Centralization of cloud services
While the "turn off the internet" claim is hyperbole, the recent outage does highlight a legitimate concern: the increasing consolidation of infrastructure with a few tech giants. The outage revealed how dependent modern life is on the reliability of services like AWS, impacting banking, media, and other crucial sectors.

This concentration of power has led to calls for regulation, with some figures like Senator Elizabeth Warren arguing that companies whose failure can "break the entire internet" have grown too big.

Genesis AI