Lehman Brothers Financial SA (LEHNQ)

[cottonisking]

✈️ BULLWIT is easy to see while waiting on your 2029 flights in an airport, over several decades:

The value of Lehman Brothers' bankruptcy distributions was significantly eroded by the time value of money. While the total nominal amount eventually distributed was substantial, the 14-year delay in payments meant that the actual purchasing power received by creditors was far less than what they were owed at the time of the 2008 bankruptcy.
The impact of time value of money
The time value of money is the concept that a sum of money is worth more now than the same sum will be in the future due to its potential earning capacity. In the Lehman case, this principle was demonstrated through two major factors:
Delayed payments: The bankruptcy process was extremely complex and took years to resolve. The Lehman estate started making its first cash distributions to creditors in April 2012, nearly four years after the collapse. It took 14 years, until September 2022, to finalize the liquidation and finish paying creditors.
Lost purchasing power: Creditors received their money in periodic installments over more than a decade. A dollar paid in 2022 is worth considerably less than a dollar held in 2008 due to inflation and lost investment opportunities.
Present value calculation and lost value
To quantify this effect, economists with the Federal Reserve Bank of New York compared the nominal value of the distributions to their present value, discounted back to the time of the bankruptcy.
Nominal vs. Present Value: A 2019 analysis found that while third-party creditors received a nominal total of nearly $94 billion, the present value of those distributions was much lower.
Using Treasury yields: The present value was calculated at $80 billion, a $14 billion difference that measures the time value of money.
Using Corporate bond yields: This calculation, which also accounts for liquidity risk, showed an even lower present value of $65 billion.
Total value destruction: This analysis concluded that the lost time value and liquidity value to creditors amounted to about $29 billion ($14 billion + $15 billion), a major component of the total value destroyed by the bankruptcy.
Impact on different creditor classes
The erosion of value also affected creditors differently depending on their priority and access to capital during the long process:
Unsecured creditors: They were most impacted by the delay and loss of liquidity. Their recovery rate improved over time in nominal terms—reaching over 41 cents on the dollar, far better than the initial estimates of around 16% to 20%. However, the real, present value of those recoveries was substantially lower than the nominal figures.
Customers and secured creditors: These parties fared much better. Most customer claims were settled within weeks of the collapse and were fully satisfied, while secured creditors also received 100% of their claims. This highlights the stark difference in outcomes based on a creditor's position.
Market-wide impact: The delay in distributions also meant creditors couldn't use their money to reinvest and generate returns elsewhere. This lack of liquidity caused broader market contagion effects, as seen with the collapse of the Reserve Primary Fund, a money market fund holding Lehman debt.

AI Overview



+8
The long, complex, and staggered nature of the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy distributions dramatically reduced the actual value creditors received, relative to the nominal dollar amounts they were owed. This loss in value is a direct result of the concept of the present value of money, which holds that a dollar received today is worth more than a dollar received in the future due to inflation, opportunity costs, and risk.
How the present value concept applied to Lehman's bankruptcy
Time Value of Money: The bankruptcy proceedings lasted over a decade, with distributions to creditors beginning in 2012 and continuing for years after the September 2008 filing.
For a creditor, a payout of $1 million in 2015 was less valuable than $1 million received in 2008. The funds were tied up for years, making them inaccessible for new investments or to cover other losses.
In a 2019 analysis, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York used discounted cash flow techniques to quantify this loss. When adjusting the $94 billion in nominal distributions to third-party creditors for the time value of money, they found the present value was only $80 billion (based on Treasury yields).
Lost Liquidity: A bankruptcy claim is not a liquid asset. Creditors were unable to access their funds for years and could not sell their claims for their full face value.
The Fed's analysis calculated this lost liquidity as an additional cost to creditors. By using corporate bond yields (which include a premium for illiquidity) as a discount rate instead of Treasury yields, they estimated the present value of distributions to be just $65 billion.
This shows that creditors faced two layers of lost value: the general time value of money and the specific cost of being unable to use their assets for a prolonged period.
Risk and Uncertainty: For years, creditors faced significant uncertainty about how much they would recover and when. Early estimates of the recovery rate for unsecured creditors were as low as 16%, but a strong economic recovery helped raise the final rate to over 40%.
This uncertainty was itself a cost. It prevented creditors from making reliable financial plans and led to a "liquidity crunch" for financial market participants who were exposed to Lehman.
Calculation of lost value: The Fed estimated that the costs borne by creditors for having their assets tied up in the bankruptcy proceedings amounted to $15 billion. This figure was derived directly from applying the present value concept to the distributed funds.
Key takeaways for creditors
Total nominal payments mask reality: While some Lehman entities paid out 100 cents on the dollar to certain types of creditors, and others like unsecured creditors eventually recovered a higher-than-expected nominal amount, these figures don't tell the whole story. The long delays meant the real economic value received was significantly lower.
Liquidation timeline matters: The Lehman case demonstrated that the length of the bankruptcy process is a critical factor for creditors. Delays, even if they result in a better eventual settlement, can dramatically erode the real value of the recovery.
Present value is not just theoretical: For Lehman creditors, the present value of money was not an abstract concept. It was a tangible and significant loss of billions of dollars in real wealth that was quantified by financial experts after the process concluded.