arbitrary objects and being able to change parts of the software without changing the whole deal?
i asked gemini ai how to make nvda h20 compiliant with T chip regs , but you know how changeable his rules could be, maybe they use some sbv/vcsy ip for device soft fabric and monitoring of it's functions?
"what modifications could nvda apply to the h2o chip to make it acceptable for china sales under the new chip rules of usa?
Show thinking
NVIDIA is continuously navigating the complex and evolving landscape of U.S. export controls on advanced AI chips to China. The H20 chip itself was designed as a China-specific variant to comply with previous rounds of restrictions. However, recent reports indicate that even the H20 now requires an export license, prompting NVIDIA to consider further modifications.
To make the H20 (or a subsequent derivative) acceptable for China sales under new or tightened U.S. chip rules, NVIDIA would need to implement further de-tuning or modifications to ensure the chip's performance metrics fall below the specific thresholds set by the U.S. Department of Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS).
Based on recent reports, here are the types of modifications or considerations NVIDIA might apply to the H20:
Reduced Memory Capacity (HBM): This is a key area for de-tuning. The H20 already had scaled-back performance compared to NVIDIA's top-tier chips like the H100/A100. Reports indicate that the latest modified version of the H20 for China will feature substantially reduced High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) capacity. HBM is critical for feeding data to the GPU's processing units efficiently, impacting the chip's ability to train large language models and handle large AI workloads. The U.S. regulations also specifically target HBM stacks that meet certain memory bandwidth density criteria.
Lowered Performance Thresholds: The U.S. export controls define performance limits based on metrics such as "total processing performance" (TPP) and "performance density." NVIDIA would need to ensure the modified H20's specifications (e.g., Tensor Core performance, FP32/FP16 throughput) fall below these thresholds.
The original H20 featured around 296 TeraFLOPS of mixed-precision compute power and 74 TeraFLOPS of single-precision (FP32) throughput. Further modifications would likely reduce these numbers.
Restricted Interconnect Bandwidth: Previous de-tuning efforts on chips like the H800 (an earlier China-specific chip) involved reducing the interconnect bandwidth between GPUs in a server, which limits the scalability of large AI training clusters. While the H20 had higher interconnects, any new restrictions might target this aspect again.
Enhanced Interface/Module Adjustments: One report suggests that the modified H20 chip might feature an "enhanced interface connecting to server CPUs," allowing NVIDIA to achieve technical compliance while preserving some performance. Additionally, sources have mentioned that downstream customers might potentially be able to "modify the chip's module configuration to adjust performance levels," though the extent and legality of such customer modifications under U.S. rules would be critical.
Compliance with Supercomputer End-Use Restrictions: Recent U.S. regulations have increasingly targeted the use of AI chips in "supercomputers," as defined by the Export Administration Regulations (EAR). Even if an individual chip falls below certain performance thresholds, if it's intended for use in a cluster that collectively exceeds supercomputer performance limits, it may still require an export license. NVIDIA's modifications would need to consider this "cumulative performance" aspect.
Challenges and Implications:
Evolving Regulations: The U.S. export control rules are dynamic, with continuous updates and clarifications. This creates a "cat-and-mouse game" where NVIDIA constantly has to adjust its designs to meet new thresholds.
Balancing Compliance and Market Demand: NVIDIA faces the challenge of designing chips that are sufficiently de-tuned to comply with U.S. rules but still powerful enough to be attractive to Chinese customers, who are increasingly looking for alternatives from domestic chipmakers like Huawei.
Financial Impact: The uncertainty and continuous redesigns lead to significant inventory write-downs and impact NVIDIA's revenue from a crucial market like China.
Ultimately, NVIDIA's goal is to develop chips that are legally permissible for sale in China while still offering competitive performance for AI inference and, to a lesser extent, training within the defined regulatory boundaries.
Sources and related content
"
AI
Market Data 
Markets 
