Well Clinton was right as after NAFTA we got more good paying jobs than we lost. You seem to be upset that the workers who lost jobs couldn't get other jobs or didn't have the skills to get other good paying jobs. Automation was also replacing jobs on the assembly lines but wait till AI gets going and robotics. Workers at all levels will be at risk so they have to be nimble and have multiple talents unlike the workers who could not find good jobs after NAFTA. It's survival of the fittest so keep voting against your interests. It seems to be working out for West Virginia.