According to Fawesome (He is a lawyer)the case is dead and their chance for success with an appeal is unlikely to succeed also. I thought this case was about Patent infringement. I don't believe what Batten did would ever be allowed in a Civil or Criminal case. If a plantiff states he has 10 credible witnesses on his behalf and the judge decides one of them is not credible, do you disallow the other 9?? HCMC had pages and pages of evidence that was thrown out on a lawyer technical error. Does not seem fair.
Market Data 
Markets
