Sunday, January 29, 2017 4:35:42 PM
Obi,
I've cut and pasted the excel numbers below. It assumes the 5% rate is used from the start as per Cap's 491 and applying all the payments to interest / then to principal.
Once the loan is repaid; it pays Freddie $$ at 5% same as it was re-charged.
Old Old Old Old Old Old New New New New New
Date Rate Int Charged Draw Paid Bal Rate Int Recalc Draw Paid Bal
9/30/2008 10% - 13.800 0 13.800 5% - 13.800 0 13.800
12/31/2008 10% 0.167 30.800 0.167 44.60 5% 0.084 30.80 0.167 44.52
3/31/2009 10% 0.370 6.100 0.370 50.70 5% 0.185 6.100 0.370 50.43
6/30/2009 10% 1.149 - 1.149 50.70 5% 0.571 - 1.149 49.85
9/30/2009 10% 1.294 - 1.294 50.70 5% 0.636 - 1.294 49.20
12/31/2009 10% 1.293 - 1.293 50.70 5% 0.627 - 1.293 48.53
3/31/2010 10% 1.293 10.600 1.293 61.30 5% 0.619 10.600 1.293 58.46
6/30/2010 10% 1.293 1.800 1.293 63.10 5% 0.617 1.80 1.293 59.58
9/30/2010 10% 1.560 0.100 1.560 63.20 5% 0.736 0.100 1.560 58.86
12/31/2010 10% 1.603 0.500 1.603 63.70 5% 0.746 0.50 1.603 58.50
3/31/2011 10% 1.605 - 1.605 63.70 5% 0.737 - 1.605 57.63
6/30/2011 10% 1.618 1.479 1.618 65.18 5% 0.732 1.48 1.618 58.22
9/30/2011 10% 1.618 5.992 1.618 71.17 5% 0.723 5.992 1.618 63.32
12/13/2011 10% 1.655 0.146 1.655 71.32 5% 0.736 0.15 1.655 62.55
3/31/2012 10% 1.808 0.019 1.808 71.34 5% 0.793 0.019 1.808 61.55
6/30/2012 10% 1.808 - 1.808 71.34 5% 0.780 - 1.808 60.52
9/30/2012 10% 1.808 - 1.808 71.34 5% 0.767 - 1.808 59.48
12/31/2012 10% 1.808 - 1.808 71.34 5% 0.754 - 1.808 58.43
3/31/2013 Sweep 5.826 - 5.826 71.34 5% 0.730 - 5.826 53.33
6/30/2013 na 6.971 - 6.971 71.34 5% 0.667 - 6.971 47.03
9/30/2013 na 4.357 - 4.357 71.34 5% 0.588 - 4.357 43.26
12/31/2013 na 30.436 - 30.436 71.34 5% 0.541 - 30.436 13.36
3/31/2014 na 10.435 - 10.435 71.34 5% 0.167 - 10.435 3.10
6/30/2014 na 4.499 - 4.499 71.34 5% 0.039 - 4.499 (1.36)
9/30/2014 na 1.890 - 1.890 71.34 5% (0.017) - 1.890 (3.27)
12/31/2014 na 2.786 - 2.786 71.34 5% (0.041) - 2.786 (6.10)
3/31/2015 na 0.851 - 0.851 71.34 5% (0.076) - 0.851 (7.02)
6/30/2015 na 0.746 - 0.746 71.34 5% (0.088) - 0.746 (7.86)
9/30/2015 na 3.913 - 3.913 71.34 5% (0.098) - 3.913 (11.87)
12/31/2015 na - - - 71.34 5% (0.148) - - (12.02)
3/31/2016 na 1.740 - 1.740 71.34 5% (0.150) - 1.740 (13.91)
6/30/2016 na - - - 71.34 5% (0.174) - - (14.08)
9/30/2016 na 0.933 - 0.933 71.34 5% (0.176) - 0.933 (15.19)
12/31/2016 na 2.310 - 2.310 71.34 5% (0.190) - 2.310 (17.69)
Totals Totals 101.443 71.336 101.443 Totals Totals 12.416 71.336 101.443 Totals
If you can put this in a spread sheet you'll see the power of compounding!
At 5% - they'd owe Freddie $18Billion!
Fannie is done and recalculated the same way. It results in a higher amount owed.
If they do this you can forget that 30 year amort thing.
Next to your question of what happens. Well that's not up to me; but i couldn't imagine they'd not be free. Also, keep in mind the tax benefit of re-characterizing this as interest payments. Freddie would have to show the expense and the tax benefit of the interest expense.
This would be great.
JM
Enjoy.
I've cut and pasted the excel numbers below. It assumes the 5% rate is used from the start as per Cap's 491 and applying all the payments to interest / then to principal.
Once the loan is repaid; it pays Freddie $$ at 5% same as it was re-charged.
Old Old Old Old Old Old New New New New New
Date Rate Int Charged Draw Paid Bal Rate Int Recalc Draw Paid Bal
9/30/2008 10% - 13.800 0 13.800 5% - 13.800 0 13.800
12/31/2008 10% 0.167 30.800 0.167 44.60 5% 0.084 30.80 0.167 44.52
3/31/2009 10% 0.370 6.100 0.370 50.70 5% 0.185 6.100 0.370 50.43
6/30/2009 10% 1.149 - 1.149 50.70 5% 0.571 - 1.149 49.85
9/30/2009 10% 1.294 - 1.294 50.70 5% 0.636 - 1.294 49.20
12/31/2009 10% 1.293 - 1.293 50.70 5% 0.627 - 1.293 48.53
3/31/2010 10% 1.293 10.600 1.293 61.30 5% 0.619 10.600 1.293 58.46
6/30/2010 10% 1.293 1.800 1.293 63.10 5% 0.617 1.80 1.293 59.58
9/30/2010 10% 1.560 0.100 1.560 63.20 5% 0.736 0.100 1.560 58.86
12/31/2010 10% 1.603 0.500 1.603 63.70 5% 0.746 0.50 1.603 58.50
3/31/2011 10% 1.605 - 1.605 63.70 5% 0.737 - 1.605 57.63
6/30/2011 10% 1.618 1.479 1.618 65.18 5% 0.732 1.48 1.618 58.22
9/30/2011 10% 1.618 5.992 1.618 71.17 5% 0.723 5.992 1.618 63.32
12/13/2011 10% 1.655 0.146 1.655 71.32 5% 0.736 0.15 1.655 62.55
3/31/2012 10% 1.808 0.019 1.808 71.34 5% 0.793 0.019 1.808 61.55
6/30/2012 10% 1.808 - 1.808 71.34 5% 0.780 - 1.808 60.52
9/30/2012 10% 1.808 - 1.808 71.34 5% 0.767 - 1.808 59.48
12/31/2012 10% 1.808 - 1.808 71.34 5% 0.754 - 1.808 58.43
3/31/2013 Sweep 5.826 - 5.826 71.34 5% 0.730 - 5.826 53.33
6/30/2013 na 6.971 - 6.971 71.34 5% 0.667 - 6.971 47.03
9/30/2013 na 4.357 - 4.357 71.34 5% 0.588 - 4.357 43.26
12/31/2013 na 30.436 - 30.436 71.34 5% 0.541 - 30.436 13.36
3/31/2014 na 10.435 - 10.435 71.34 5% 0.167 - 10.435 3.10
6/30/2014 na 4.499 - 4.499 71.34 5% 0.039 - 4.499 (1.36)
9/30/2014 na 1.890 - 1.890 71.34 5% (0.017) - 1.890 (3.27)
12/31/2014 na 2.786 - 2.786 71.34 5% (0.041) - 2.786 (6.10)
3/31/2015 na 0.851 - 0.851 71.34 5% (0.076) - 0.851 (7.02)
6/30/2015 na 0.746 - 0.746 71.34 5% (0.088) - 0.746 (7.86)
9/30/2015 na 3.913 - 3.913 71.34 5% (0.098) - 3.913 (11.87)
12/31/2015 na - - - 71.34 5% (0.148) - - (12.02)
3/31/2016 na 1.740 - 1.740 71.34 5% (0.150) - 1.740 (13.91)
6/30/2016 na - - - 71.34 5% (0.174) - - (14.08)
9/30/2016 na 0.933 - 0.933 71.34 5% (0.176) - 0.933 (15.19)
12/31/2016 na 2.310 - 2.310 71.34 5% (0.190) - 2.310 (17.69)
Totals Totals 101.443 71.336 101.443 Totals Totals 12.416 71.336 101.443 Totals
If you can put this in a spread sheet you'll see the power of compounding!
At 5% - they'd owe Freddie $18Billion!
Fannie is done and recalculated the same way. It results in a higher amount owed.
If they do this you can forget that 30 year amort thing.
Next to your question of what happens. Well that's not up to me; but i couldn't imagine they'd not be free. Also, keep in mind the tax benefit of re-characterizing this as interest payments. Freddie would have to show the expense and the tax benefit of the interest expense.
This would be great.
JM
Enjoy.
Recent FNMA News
- Fannie Mae Releases February 2026 Monthly Summary • PR Newswire (US) • 03/26/2026 08:05:00 PM
- Fannie Mae Announces Results of Tender Offer for Any and All of Certain CAS Notes • PR Newswire (US) • 03/02/2026 02:00:00 PM
- Fannie Mae Releases January 2026 Monthly Summary • PR Newswire (US) • 02/26/2026 09:05:00 PM
- Fannie Mae Announces Tender Offer for Any and All of Certain CAS Notes • PR Newswire (US) • 02/23/2026 02:00:00 PM
