Somewhere along the line, Ksquared, I mostly quit using After Shave and Cologne. Maybe it was when the deodorants began having a variety of scents. I have a small bottle of Expensive Stuff that someone gave me, and I'll use a small squirt for special occasions that are very infrequent. Also have a bottle of shower gel that a department store was giving away. It's called Tommy's Juiced Up and has a citrus aroma. I've used it a time or two, even though I'm just a bit concerned about smelling "fruity" .... <gg>
Just the name Old Spice calls to mind the old-school gentlemen of earlier generations. Near the English Leather in the back of my closet is a bottle of Old Spice After Shave. It resembles a miniature milk bottle with a tall sailing ship painted on it. It opened easily and still has the aroma of my late dad.
English Leather had a TV ad in which a young lady seductively told us, "All my men wear English Leather, or they wear nothing at all." Ksquared, since you can't remember the smell of English Leather, are we to assume that your young men fell into Group B ... ? <g>
Justin, wearing nothing at all (north of my tee shirt, that is)