Replies to post #15236 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

You and i agreed on most but....

..

Not all.

My take...

Tonight was one of my all time fav shows over the years, mostly really good entertainment.

Walker- didnt like the song choice but then it grew on me, LOVED the harmonies. B

Kate- (i must say, pat benitar looked amazing for her age and all)... ok, back to Kate. She sang way too soft and blew it. C-

Riley- still too weak and soft as well. C

Uche’- fun upbeat island song but he sucked, and shaggy did all the work. D

Madison- she was too nervous and kept playing with her hair. C-

Shawn- omg, the pro messed up and later blamed him for it, and he was a drama queen, it was a train wreck.

Ashley- WOWZA!! Perfect, great harmony, fantastic! A+++

Bumbly- too soft and she was awkward on stage. D

Laci- sorry but i hated it. I think you liked it. D

Laine- great job but a very rushed version, should have slowed it down. I dont know who the pro (lady) was but that nasty tattoo on her fatty boob hanging out was NOT attractive. B

Kate, Shawn and bumbly go home. Thank God they kept Laine (for now at least)

[ONEBGG]

Again we agree, I could have cut 5 as well, and Elle King was terrible in the duet on The Weight.

[SSKILLZ1]

My Take on the Show

1) Alyssa- I thought it was a very good duet and I thought Alyssa had a very good vocal. Should be safe. Grade A-

2) Eddie- First of all there seemed to be confusion by Eddie when he was suppose to come in and sing. His vocal wasn't good and I'm being nice. I could of did without the I'm gonna be more serious and the bunny hop on to the stage to enter wasn't for me either. Grade D+

3) Wade- A decent vocal, not my favorite song. But we have heard him better than last night as well. Grade B-

4) Ryan- I don't love the song, but ryan can sing, but the song held the overall performance back. I heard him better. But still decent. Grade B-

5) Evelyn- Her voice, your either gonna like or really dislike. I happen to like her unique tone, but for anyone who says she is terrible I completely get that. Even though I actually don't mind her tone, the song kind of sucked the life out of the room which was problem. And her vocal was above average for me. Grade C+

6) Logan- I thought it was a average performance at best. This past week including the solos his voiced was exposed as not that strong. Should go home. Grade C-

7) Raquel- As usual she doesn't let me down, another one that kept getting through that I didn't understand. She had another terrible vocal and was easily the worst of the night in my opinion. Grade D-

8) Alejandro- I'm not alejandro fan, but what I will say is each time I see him the dislike is fading, and he is actually starting to grow on me so to speak. Nobody will ever confuse him with someone with great range, but did Kind of like that duet I have to admit. Grade B-

9) Dimitrius- I thought for the most part he sang very well although I wasn't in love with the one note towards the end. Without a doubt he had the best partner of the night in my opinion by the way so that does help. But I tried to keep it focused on Dimitrious. Grade B

10) Jeremiah- I thought it was a very good duet, and I thought jeremiah sang excellently. Another very good performance. Grade A-

I would of cut
Eddie
Raquel
Logan

They cut
Raquel-I 100% Agree with
Logan- See Raquel.
Ryan- Disagreed with how they put Eddie through after all those issues is baffling to me.

Well will see when America vote next week to go from 14 to 10. anyways that's that. All is just my opinion of course.