AMERICAN IDOL

[gail]

You and i agreed on most but....

..

Not all.

My take...

Tonight was one of my all time fav shows over the years, mostly really good entertainment.

Walker- didnt like the song choice but then it grew on me, LOVED the harmonies. B

Kate- (i must say, pat benitar looked amazing for her age and all)... ok, back to Kate. She sang way too soft and blew it. C-

Riley- still too weak and soft as well. C

Uche’- fun upbeat island song but he sucked, and shaggy did all the work. D

Madison- she was too nervous and kept playing with her hair. C-

Shawn- omg, the pro messed up and later blamed him for it, and he was a drama queen, it was a train wreck.

Ashley- WOWZA!! Perfect, great harmony, fantastic! A+++

Bumbly- too soft and she was awkward on stage. D

Laci- sorry but i hated it. I think you liked it. D

Laine- great job but a very rushed version, should have slowed it down. I dont know who the pro (lady) was but that nasty tattoo on her fatty boob hanging out was NOT attractive. B

Kate, Shawn and bumbly go home. Thank God they kept Laine (for now at least)