Wow. That's a lot of ?? But ok you are entitled to your opinion. You Met fans think a LOT of McNeil, huh?
And look at Conforto's numbers and take Hicks on the Yanks except for last year when he was injured, but compare 2018.
Almost the same, Hicks and Conforto.
And Hicks is like our 6th best player, behind Judge, LeMahieu, Torres, Stanton, and Sanchez. Of course if all stay healthy too.
Conforto is good as I think Hicks is good, but they are not GREAT.
And McNeil "could" be GREAT? Another 3 years like he has had in a bit over a year and I will say he is GREAT.
NOT NOW.
And Alonso also could be GREAT with another year or 2 like last year?
What made Jeter and Mariano GREAT?
They did it for 20 years, not 1 or 2 years.
TROUT is GREAT
BETTS is GREAT
Torres on Yanks now 2 GREAT years, BUT he needs to do more, as does Judge, and Sanchez.
Stanton won MVP 2 years ago, DJ LeMahieu won batting title years ago,
Yes Judge and Alonso have won rookie of the year (Alonso will soon) and home run champs, but still need to do more to be GREAT.
I think Betts is GREAT and he will get a contract to prove it. If anyone gets him as a "rental" for one year, he "could" help them win it all, and then TRY to sign him as can anyone else.
He is NOT just offense, he is a GREAT fielder, as is Judge.
