Replies to post #14355 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[SSKILLZ1]

My Take on the Show

Malaya- was excellent, I agree with the judges she by far was the best of the night. Grade A

Alex- Did a very good job, was very creative with that song, he is a bit of a scientist though sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. Tonight it worked big time. Grade A-

Jena- Excellent vocal, not the best singing song, but she did real well. I disagree with you on her, because almost all the times you like her, she is one of the two best female singers in my opinion. Grade B+

Caleb- He and jena are my two favorites, he also like jena sang a song excellently and did the best he could with that song. Grade B+

Sam- Solid vocal, but missing something. Grade C+

Dexter- Bad song Choice. Mediocre at best vocal. Far from his best. Not as bad as MK, but was the worst he has been in my opinion. Grade C-

Jessica- First half of song was very shakey, was waaay better in the second half. don't love her tone either. Grade C-

CJ- Last week appear to be a anomaly to his usual off key, not so great sounding performance. here is yet another example of that. Grade D-

MK- Forgot words. Sang Flat a lot of the song. Bad performance. I totally agree with you on her. Grade D-

Majesty- She was fearful in the beginning, she sang badly. worst performance of the night. Grade F

The bottom 3
CJ
MK
Majesty

The Cut
Majesty

All is just my opinion, and I could always be wrong though.