Replies to post #14356 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

i have said all along that majesty needs to go, but i think it will be cj first. he is way worse, then her next week to go.

[SSKILLZ1]

My Take on the Show

Overall pretty good show tonight.

Caleb-He has mind blowing skills vocally, and tonight he was outrageously good waaaaaaaay better then last week, and he is never bad. best of the night. Grade A+

Jena- Had the tough task of going after caleb, and she did an excellent job, picked a good song, and hit the mind blowing power notes at the end. Grade A

Malaya- Sang the song a little slower then I would like, but her vocal was about as good as it get. Perfect control, solid power. She is a excellent singer. Grade A-

Alex- I thought he was very solid. Now his take which although is clearly alex, was not as good as the original. Having said that I really enjoyed it. Grade B+

Dexter- I thought he sang real well, he did a real solid job. Not great but solid. Grade B

Jessica- Was good in parts, but also had some bad note in there as well. decent for her. Grade C+

Majesty- Miles better then last week. Performance was very good, vocal was so-so. Grade C-

Sam-Sing on one plane the whole song, sing with absolutely no feeling and does not connect with the audience. I didn't like it. Grade D

CJ- Sang with no emotion. and literally fell off a cliff in the middle of the performance. Grade D-

My Bottom 3
CJ
SAM
Majesty

My Cut
CJ


All is just my opinion, and I could always be wrong though.