Replies to post #13119 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[XV19]

I've said it over and over.. until the Voting Rules change on Idol, too many great talents will just go by the wayside. Sad to say, but it's time to take America OUT of American Idol.

I think that really is the main reason Simon left to do his XFactor things. Qualified judgeds pick the winners. As it should be.