Biotech Values

[Double_Bagel]

Rockrat, thanks for your analysis. From the table of contents in the document, doesn't the inequitable conduct case seem to be rather strong for MNTA? This is pretty harsh stuff about Dr. Pinchasi. This is just from a cursory glance of the table of contents


FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW RELATING TO
DEFENDANTS’ INEQUITABLE CONDUCT DEFENSE ......................... 222

...
...

(v) Dr. Pinchasi’s Intent to Deceive ....................................................... 260

(1) Dr. Pinchasi’s Lacked Credibility .................................................... 260

(2) Dr. Pinchasi’s Documents Do Not Establish Good Faith ..................... 262

(3) Dr. Pinchasi’s Motive to Lie to the PTO ............................................ 269

(4) Dr. Pinchasi Took Inconsistent Positions With the FDA and PTO ........ 273


C.Conclusions of Law ................................................................. 277

(i) The Materiality of the April 1994 Data Table and the RBL
Degranulation Information........................................................... 277

(ii) Dr. Pinchasi Had An Intent to Deceive the PTO ......................... 285