Barry,
Regarding my question to you about the SA being similar to the TA for the Sell Mode, you are quite correct. I realise now that in the Sell Mode the SA has a similar problem with a Residual Sell Advice due to the reduction of the Sell Order relative to the Sell Advice! Good Point!
In regards to TANGENT message ¾ I do not quarrel with your calculations. I do observe that the practice of letting the SAFE enter into the magnitude Buy Order using the factor (1+B) or
(1-B) makes everything cumbersome and less than lucid. Now, I know that the Tangent AIM and the Hybrid AIM are intended to be improvements, I question if it is not simpler to only use the SAFE only as a Filter to decide: To Buy or Not to Buy.
After that is done it would seem a simpler method to temper the SELL or the BUY with a scaling factor:
For any share price Outside the Hold Zone
Buy=(PC-Y)*S
Where the S is chosen simply as a scaling factor.
Now for the Buy Mode in your Hybrid AIM
This is, if I understand it correctly, identical to the Vortex Method in that you arrive at a the same solution as Qarel showed some time ago:
PC + C1*Advice=PC + C1*C2*Advise (Vortex AIM terminology)
This results in G = N (Hybrid AIM terminology)
This makes your Hybrid AIM essentially the same as the Vortex AIM, as instead of using A=0,5 you can just as well use A=0,2 or any other permissible value.
Now, mind you, I do not conclude that the HA is identical to the Vortex AIM. In using the SAFE mixed up in the calculations you have essentially something different, and possibly this has some practical Effect that I cannot figure out yet.
In any case, I find it very interesting that your effort attempts to have the motivation to eliminate that irritating Lichello Feature. Now all we have to do is to find out if there are any advantages, other than the obvious one of elegance!
I will attempt to post a stock history on the Board that you and others can use as a short Test Case. The idea is that anyone use the stock history to get a Yield at the end of 85 weeks running. At this time I have no rules for the test other than the the boundary conditions be the same...Be my guest. I hope I can put the stock history on the Board.
Regards,
Conrad
