Imo, despite the 'conspiracy'l theories, the judges got it right.
Archuletta was flawless in all 3 songs. He has the better voice, and based on tonight, he should win the contest hands down and walking away.
Cook would have needed a little touching up in the editing process if they were using tonights songs for a recording.
However, again in imo, Cook will have more success in the long run. His style is much more suited to todays listeners who aren't into the slower ballad type songs Archuletta shines on.