A catch is a catch. What happens after the catch has been going on since day one of the game. As for the rest of replay ............ Like I said in other post the FACT is the umpires due to the good old boys club very rarely ask each other for help on controversial plays. They need to be a team out there and help each other out and leave their ego on the bench. It is my position if this took place 75% of the bad calls would go away and that is a conservative estimate.